As Tenure Termination Appears to be on the Rise, What Do I Need to Know to Protect Myself?

Man walking out of office after being fired

In a rapidly transforming academic environment where tenure termination seems to be trending, it's essential for educators to understand both the nuances of tenure and how to navigate its complexities. As highlighted by the American Association of University Professors (AAUP), tenure's history and purpose serve as a testament to its critical role in higher education.

The Foundation and Function of Tenure

Academic tenure, as defined by the AAUP, is an indefinite appointment safeguarding professors against termination without just cause or under exceptional conditions such as financial exigency and program discontinuation. The bedrock of this concept is the 1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure, a pivotal document in U.S. higher education that has been widely endorsed and integrated into faculty codes and agreements across numerous institutions.

Tenure's Purpose and Importance

Tenure's primary goal is to protect academic freedom, which is indispensable for faculty members engaged in teaching and research. It's this very freedom that allows for the unhampered pursuit of knowledge, free from external pressures—be it corporate, political, or otherwise.

Tenure and the Public Good

The protection tenure affords isn't just for the benefit of individual professors—it's a bulwark for society's greater good. Tenure supports stable, long-term commitments in academia, fostering environments where faculty can mentor the next generation, engage in extended research projects, and contribute to local communities.

The State of Tenure Today

Despite its profound benefits, the presence of tenure within academia is diminishing, with only about 21 percent of the academic labor force currently holding tenured positions. This decline underlines an unsettling trend: fewer educators are shielded when tackling controversial subjects or presenting research that could challenge prevailing interests.

Who Is Eligible for Tenure?

The AAUP advocates that all full-time faculty, irrespective of rank, should be eligible for tenure and insists on fair and clear pathways to this security, including for part-time faculty.

Real-World Impacts of Academic Freedom

One example of a positive impact of tenure is the story of Marc Edwards, a professor who exposed lead contamination in drinking water. While federal grant monies and other donors ceased sending him grants or other funding, he kept his position and was able to continue his research, exemplifying a benefit of tenure. His research, which brought to light government negligence, underscores the real-world consequences when academic freedom is upheld. Without the protection of tenure, such crucial work might never reach the public eye.

What Does This Mean for You?

Understanding the integral role of tenure is the first step in safeguarding your academic career. Here are additional strategies to consider:

  1. Review the AAUP's Standards: Familiarize yourself with the detailed standards and recommendations provided by the AAUP, which outline the expectations and protections associated with tenure.
  1. Broaden Your Advocacy: Advocate for policies that support tenure pathways, especially for vulnerable part-time faculty who contribute significantly to the academic fabric.
  1. Protect Your Work: Follow in the footsteps of scholars like Marc Edwards by ensuring your research and academic pursuits are aligned with integrity and public service, which tenure is designed to protect.
  1. Seek Support: In the face of challenges to tenure, seek support from organizations like the AAUP and legal experts with special knowledge and experience in higher-education employment law navigate potential disputes.

As the academic landscape evolves, tenure remains a critical aspect of ensuring the freedom and integrity of scholarly work. By staying informed and proactive, educators can better navigate the complexities of tenure and reinforce the pillars of academic freedom that benefit us all.

If you are facing concerns related to a similar issue or if you have questions about your Employment situation, please feel free to contact us here. We have many years of experience handling such matters and will be able to assist you in resolving the dispute. We are referred to professors with employment questions by the Association of American University Professors (AAUP), as we have long been on the AAUP referral list.

To learn more about these topics, you may want to review our information provided on these pages: Employment Law, Higher Education, Academic Freedom, Tenure, Faculty Appointments, Promotion Denials and Related Issues, Challenges to Scholarly Work, and Contract Termination.

You may learn more about us and how we operate by visiting these pages: About Us, What Sets Us Apart, and Learn More About Us.