Skip to Content
Top

Business Divorce Meets Marital Divorce: What Happens When Divorcing Spouses Own a Business Together?

Conference table with stacks of papers.
|

When divorcing spouses own a business together, they may be facing two separations at the same time: the end of their marriage and the end—or restructuring—of their business relationship.

For business owners, that distinction matters.

A traditional divorce analysis often focuses on whether a business interest is marital or separate property, what the business is worth, and how that value should be distributed between the spouses. But when both spouses have ownership or management rights in the company, valuation may be only part of the problem.

Someone still has to run the business.

Who controls the bank accounts? Who can sign contracts? Can either spouse make major expenditures? Can one owner remove the other from management? What happens when the spouses disagree about distributions, employees, financing, or the future direction of the company? And what can a court do if their personal dispute begins threatening the value of the business itself?

In a high-asset divorce involving a closely held company, protecting the business during the litigation can be just as important as determining who ultimately receives its value.

Key Takeaways

  • A divorce between spouses who own a business together can create both a matrimonial dispute and a business-ownership dispute.
  • Determining the value of the business does not necessarily resolve questions about ownership, management, voting rights, distributions, and control.
  • New York's automatic orders and the court's equitable powers can restrict actions that threaten marital assets while a divorce is pending.
  • In appropriate circumstances, a court may consider significant interim remedies—including injunctive relief or a temporary receiver—to protect business assets.
  • The ultimate solution may involve a buyout, sale, restructuring, continued ownership, or other negotiated separation of the spouses' business interests.
  • Business owners should address control and preservation issues early. A profitable company can lose substantial value while the parties spend months or years litigating who gets it.

A Business Can Create a Second Divorce

Consider a company owned 50/50 by a married couple.

While the marriage is functioning, the spouses may make decisions informally. One may handle operations while the other manages finances. They may agree on compensation, distributions, investments, hiring, borrowing, and long-term strategy without focusing closely on the company's governing documents.

Divorce changes that dynamic. The spouses may suddenly disagree about issues that previously required cooperation. A routine business decision can become part of the matrimonial dispute, while disagreements arising from the marriage can spill directly into the company.

That can create a classic business deadlock at exactly the time the spouses are also litigating their divorce.

The legal problem therefore becomes broader than: What is the business worth?

It may also become: How do we keep the business operating and preserve its value until the parties can separate their economic interests?

Ownership, Value, and Control Are Different Questions

A spouse's economic interest in a company is not necessarily the same thing as the right to manage or control that company.

Depending on the entity and its governing documents, the parties may have separate rights involving:

Those distinctions can become important during a divorce.

For example, determining that a spouse has an economic interest in a company does not automatically answer whether that spouse can participate in management. Likewise, determining the marital value of an ownership interest does not necessarily tell the parties who should operate the company while the divorce remains pending.

That is where matrimonial law and business law intersect and can begin to overlap.

Can One Spouse Change the Business During the Divorce?

Once a New York matrimonial action begins, automatic orders generally restrict both parties from transferring, selling, assigning, encumbering, concealing, or otherwise disposing of property without the other party's consent or a court order, subject to recognized exceptions such as transactions in the usual course of business.

For business owners, the distinction between an ordinary business transaction and an action that alters ownership or value can become extremely important.

Suppose one spouse attempts to:

  • transfer an ownership interest;
  • amend an operating agreement;
  • remove the other spouse's management rights;
  • move significant assets;
  • incur unusual debt;
  • redirect revenue;
  • change control of related entities; or
  • restructure the company in a way that affects the other spouse's economic interest.

Those actions can create issues extending far beyond ordinary equitable distribution.

A court may have to determine whether immediate intervention is necessary to preserve the marital estate and prevent the business from being fundamentally changed before the divorce is resolved.

Who Runs the Company While the Divorce Is Pending?

This can be one of the most difficult practical questions.

Businesses cannot simply stop operating while their owners litigate.

Employees need to be paid. Customers and clients need service. Vendors need decisions. Loans and leases have obligations. Taxes must be addressed. Contracts may need to be negotiated. Opportunities may disappear if management cannot act quickly.

If both spouses have management authority but can no longer work together, the company may face paralysis.

At the other extreme, allowing one spouse unrestricted control may create concerns that the controlling spouse could change the business, manipulate compensation or distributions, move assets, or make decisions that reduce the other spouse's interest.

The objective should ordinarily be to preserve both enterprise value and accountability while the parties determine the company's future.

Depending on the circumstances, potential solutions may include negotiated management protocols, limitations on extraordinary transactions, enhanced financial reporting, injunctions, or other court-imposed protections.

Can a Divorce Court Put Someone Else in Control?

In extraordinary circumstances, a New York matrimonial court may consider appointing a temporary receiver to protect property involved in the divorce.

A receiver is a neutral person appointed by the court who can be given authority over property or business operations for purposes of preservation and protection.

Receivership is not a routine remedy. Removing management authority from business owners is significant, and courts generally require circumstances justifying that level of intervention.

But where an ownership dispute threatens the asset itself, the question may become whether leaving the existing management structure in place presents a greater risk than judicial intervention.

For business owners, the prospect of a receiver also illustrates why these disputes should be addressed early. Once the conflict reaches the point where a court is considering placing a third party between the owners and their company, the owners may have already lost significant control over the outcome.

Can the Divorce Court Dissolve the Business?

Not necessarily.

The authority to distribute marital property and the authority to dissolve a business entity are different legal concepts.

The answer can depend on several factors, including the type of entity, where it was formed, who owns it, the governing documents, the relief requested, and the court's jurisdiction.

A matrimonial court may have broad authority to protect marital property and determine the spouses' respective economic rights without necessarily having unlimited authority to dissolve every entity involved in the dispute.

That distinction becomes important when the company has additional owners, investors, lenders, or other parties whose rights extend beyond the divorcing spouses.

What About Other Owners and Investors?

Many businesses involved in divorce are not owned solely by the married couple.

A spouse may own 25% of a professional practice, 40% of a family company, or a membership interest in an LLC with several unrelated investors.

Those third parties are not getting divorced.

Their rights—and the company's contractual obligations to them—cannot simply be ignored because one owner's marriage is ending.

The company's shareholder agreement, operating agreement, partnership agreement, buy-sell provisions, transfer restrictions, and other governing documents can therefore become very important.

The practical objective may be to separate the spouses' financial interests without unnecessarily damaging the company or the rights of the people who remain in business together.

Valuation is Only Part of the Solution

Much of the discussion surrounding businesses in divorce focuses on valuation.

Valuation is obviously important. But sophisticated business-owner divorces often require a second question: What happens to the company after we know what it is worth?

Possible outcomes can include:

  • one spouse buying out the other's interest;
  • selling the company and dividing the resulting value;
  • restructuring ownership;
  • separating different business interests or assets;
  • continuing joint ownership under a new governance structure; or
  • pursuing dissolution or another business-law remedy when appropriate.

The right solution depends on the business, the parties, available liquidity, tax considerations, financing, governing agreements, third-party interests, and whether the spouses have any realistic ability to remain business partners after the marriage ends.

Protect the Business Before Fighting Over its Value

A closely held business may represent years—or decades—of work. It may provide the family's income, employ other people, own substantial assets, and constitute one of the largest components of the marital estate.

Allowing a divorce dispute to damage that business can hurt both spouses.

That is why business owner divorces require more than simply asking what percentage of the company's value belongs to each party.

The parties and their attorneys should also be asking:

How do we protect the company while the divorce is pending? Who should control it? What decisions require agreement? What financial information must be exchanged? And what is the most effective way to separate the parties' business interests without destroying the value they are fighting over?

When business divorce and marital divorce collide, early strategy matters.

How The Glennon Law Firm Can Help

The Glennon Law Firm represents business owners, professionals, executives, and other individuals in complex disputes involving substantial income, business interests, and other significant assets.

Cases involving jointly owned businesses can require an understanding of both matrimonial litigation and the business-law issues surrounding ownership, control, governance, valuation, fiduciary obligations, injunctions, and other remedies.

Our approach is to identify the client's objectives early, protect the assets at issue, and develop a strategy designed to reach a practical solution.

If you are facing a divorce involving a closely held business or a dispute over business ownership or control, contact The Glennon Law Firm to discuss your situation.

Personal Strategy Wins Every Time.®

With offices in Albany, Buffalo, Rochester, and New York City, we can help you across New York state. You may learn more about us and how we operate by visiting these pages: About Us and What Sets Us Apart.   

To learn more about these topics, check out our other related blog posts, including:    

This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal counsel, please contact our office directly.