One of the most common misconceptions about arbitration is that an unfavorable result can be appealed in the same way as a court decision. It cannot.
The Standard is Not Error—it is Breakdown
Courts do not review arbitration awards for:
- legal mistakes
- factual errors
- misinterpretations
Those issues are, by design, outside judicial review. Instead, a party seeking to vacate an award must establish something far more fundamental:
- corruption, fraud, or misconduct
- arbitrator bias
- failure to follow statutory procedure
- or that the arbitrator exceeded authority
Even then, the burden is substantial. Courts repeatedly emphasize that arbitration awards are entitled to extreme deference.
The Threshold is High—by Design
The rationale is straightforward: Arbitration exists to avoid:
- prolonged litigation
- appellate layers
- uncertainty
Allowing broad judicial review would undermine the very purpose of arbitration. As a result, courts will not overturn an award simply because:
- the arbitrator was wrong
- the evidence was disputed
- or the outcome appears unfair
The “Irrationality” Standard
Even arguments that an arbitrator exceeded authority face a demanding threshold. An award must be:
- irrational
- or in violation of strong public policy
This is not a low bar. It is intentionally narrow.
The Practical Reality
Most challenges fail because they are framed incorrectly. Sophisticated litigation strategy in this space requires:
- identifying procedural defects, not substantive disagreements
- understanding arbitrator authority limits
- and evaluating whether a challenge strengthens or weakens overall positioning
In many cases, the better strategy is not to attack the award, but to control what happens next in the enforcement phase.
With offices in Albany, Buffalo, Rochester, and New York City, we can help you across New York State. You may learn more about us and how we operate by visiting these pages: About Us and What Sets Us Apart.
To learn more about these topics, check out our other related blog posts and our Legalities & Realities® Podcast:
- Blog posts:
This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal counsel, please contact our office directly.